Logo

Cry of the Poor
"How can it be that even today there are still people dying of hunger? Condemned to illiteracy? Lacking the most basic medical care? Without a roof over their heads? . . .


"Christians must learn to make their act of faith in Christ by discerning His voice in the cry for help that rises from this world of poverty."
Pope John Paul II
Novo Millennio Ineunte, no. 50

Upcoming events

Why register?
All Christians and people of all faiths are welcome here!
If you want to post in forums without moderator approval, or submit blog entries, you will need to CREATE AN ACCOUNT BELOW by simply entering a username and email address. Trouble registering? We'll help: info[at]catholicsfordemocracy.org

User login
· Create new account
· Request new password

Essential Links
USCCB Faithful Citizenship
NETWORK Catholic Lobby
Democrats for Life
Bread for the World
Catholic Charities USA
Pax Christi USA
Franciscans International -- a United Nations NGO



Democracy for America
Join Democracy for America!
Follow the Webby Award People's Choice: Blog for America

Government Websites
The White House
U.S. Senate
U.S. House of Representatives
U.S. Supreme Court

Catholic Political & News Sites
Catholics for Kerry 04
Kerry Catholics
Catholics for Kerry Yahoo!
In Today's News

The Nation Weblogs
· Capital Games: New Evidence Undermines Swift Vets' Attack on Kerry
· Daily Outrage: Apocalyptic Revelations
· Daily Outrage: Abooga Rooga?
· Capital Games: Attack on Kerry Springs a Leak
· Editor's Cut: Dean's Dozens
· ActNow!: The People's Guide
· Daily Outrage: Of Mice and Men
· ActNow!: Life After Capitalism
· Editor's Cut: Protecting Every Vote
· Capital Games: Wrong for the CIA--UPDATED

Queen of Peace

Pray for Us!


 Is it possible?  
Item submitted by Unregistered on Mon 9 Aug 2004 - 20:01 h  
Watching the comments in the "About us" post at the top of the home page, I wonder whether it is physically possible for Bush supporters and Kerry supporters to have any kind of productive dialogue, especially in such an anonymous setting. Always, in a forum like this with an audience, the best strategy is to refuse to respond to your partner's (rather, opponent's) attack but to instead counter-attack on a different topic. The objective is obviously not to understand the other side in any measure, but to do everything possible to "win" in the audience's eyes.

Do I think Catholics should be able to get beyond this? Yes. But it is a lot to ask given the political climate shaped by overly macho pundits, and given that I don't expect you to focus all your peacemaking energies on a quick comment at some website.

So, I have an idea to try to forge constructive dialogue out of the tendency for combative debate described above. I will start a blog topic on a specific political issue, and commenters will be able to trade salvos about Bush and Kerry's respective positions and records on that one issue. Any comments that stray from the issue at hand will simply be deleted by me after a short interval of time (during which you will be able to judge for yourself).

Let me know what you think of this idea, and please suggest issues to try in this way.
 
  add new comment · original source · 34 reads

Post new comment
Your name:
Unregistered
Subject:
Comment:

Theodore Roosevelt

"To announce that there should be no criticism of the president, or that we are to stand by the president, right or wrong, is not only unpatriotic and servile, but is morally treasonable to the American people."


CfD News
· RNC Displaces NYC's Homeless
· RNC Displace NYC's Homeless
· Pro-Life Democrats Are Not So Naive
· UN human rights expert urges Peru, US to protect health in trade deal
· UN human rights expert urges Peru, US to protect health trade deal
· John Kerry Picks Running Mate
· 'Poverty of imagination' hinders efforts to end real poverty
· Vatican Status Raised at UN
· Changes Afoot
· Changes Afoot at CfD

Blogs
· Take Back Our Country -- Proclaim the Kingdom of God!
· The Media: Bias Right and Left!
· When Will They Ever Learn?
· Deal Hudson -- Conservative Catholic Publisher Who Cost Administrator of KerryCatholics.com His Job At USCCB
· Bush: Flip-flopper
· Speaking of Catholics for Bush...
· Catholics for Bush Got A Troll!
· Wisdom of Saint Benedict & the Founding Fathers
· Christian Law
· Education: Bush v. Kerry and vice versa

hugetim's Blog
· The Media: Bias Right and Left!
· Bush: Flip-flopper
· Education: Bush v. Kerry and vice versa
· Is it possible?
· Why Catholics Should Vote Against Bush
· Voter's Guide Seriously Flawed
· FactCheck.org is Essential
· Ratzinger: Catholics can vote Democrat!
· Forced Abortions in America: an Epidemic?
· Minimum Wage

WilliamSB's Blog
· Take Back Our Country -- Proclaim the Kingdom of God!
· When Will They Ever Learn?
· Deal Hudson -- Conservative Catholic Publisher Who Cost Administrator of KerryCatholics.com His Job At USCCB
· Deal Hudson -- Conservative Catholic Publisher Who Cost Administrator of KerryCatholics.com His Job At USCCB
· Speaking of Catholics for Bush...
· Catholics for Bush Got A Troll!
· Wisdom of Saint Benedict & the Founding Fathers
· Christian Law
· Catholic(?) League Is At It Again!
· Action Alert: New "Pax Christi, USA" Statement

CfD -- NYC
· Catholics for Democracy -- NYC

Most popular
Todays top:
· Take Back Our Country -- Proclaim the Kingdom of God!
· Catholics for Bush
· A Definition of "Pro-Life"
· Redefining Marriage: No; Expanding Benefits: Maybe
· The Media: Bias Right and Left!

Recent Discussion Topics
Discussion Forum

Reducing Abortions
Abortion Is Not a Religious Issue
How Do We Balance Issues?

CfD Books
CfD Bookstore
Book Reviews

Who's online
There are currently 0 users and 4 guests online.

Who's new
· BAM Jr in RI
· quarkspinner
· bgcurry
· onoekeh
· hawker

Comment Posting Rules
Statement about posting blog statements or responses at CfD.

Syndicate